Study
Guide for Section 4
CONFUCIANISM AND DAOISM
The
traditions originating in China represent still another type of world
religion. Like Hinduism, they are ethnically based and have
expanded because of Chinese emigration. Unlike Hinduism, however,
any "secret teachings" (seen somewhat in Daoist writings) are quite
limited and the overall approach is something we might call far more
secular than sacred. This was certainly how Jesuit missionaries
several hundred years ago regarded the so-called Chinese rites, the
patterns by which Christian converts continued to honor the spirits of
their ancestors. The philosophies of Confucianism and Daoism,
then, are more closely linked with a way of seeing individuals in their
society than they are with anything supernatural, yet popular religion
(the religious observances of ordinary people) at the same time
exhibits much the same profusion of deities and celebrations that we
have seen with both Hinduism and Buddhism.
Also, with the coming of Buddhism to China some fifteen
hundred years ago, Daoism readily borrowed from Buddhist practices by
developing its own monastic tradition. A few centuries later,
when Japan came to adopt Chinese patterns, all three
traditions--Confucianism, Daoism, and Buddhism--came to play a role in
Japanese society.
The most striking difference with what we have already seen is the
manner in which the peoples of China and Japan did not identify
themselves religiously with a single tradition. Instead, each
tradition was seen as answering particular needs, and even Christianity
could be accepted as long as it did not seem to offer a threat to other
loyalties. This can be seen as demonstrating a "both/and" or
inclusive outlook in contrast to the "either/or" or exclusive outlook
more familiar to Westerners. In Chinese or Japanese temples,
especially smaller local shrines, there can be images from all three
Asian traditions.
Since this is not a course in Asian philosophy as such, you will not
need to have much more than a surface familiarity with the dominant
themes of both Confucian and Daoist thought. You should
understand what are meant by the five relationships as well as the
central values of the fully developed person (what is otherwise
translated as "the superior man") spelled out in Confucianism, and you
should also understand how Daoist writings present the idea of reality
as a harmonous interplay of opposites (something which allowed a deeper
feeling for Buddhist views when they were brought to China).
A key contrast between the two is how society itself should be
seen. For the Confucian, society is something natural and
beneficial, and education is the key to understanding how to maintain a
good society. For the Daoist, society is something artificial and
destructive, and learning is more the problem than a solution when it
comes to how to live. In practice, however, both outlooks came to
be melded together, and familiar practices such as divination through
the I Jing reflect this.
The table below has links to material on both Chinese philosophy and
Chinese religion. For those who are using a textbook, whether the
one recommended for the course or some other, the information in the
links on the lefthand column on Chinese philosophy (from courses at
Columbia and the University of Washington) will be somewhat
repetitive. For those not using a text I encourage you to take
some time to look over what is available to get a general picture of
the philosophical background for the religious traditions as they exist
at present. Again, there are links to YouTube videos that may
allow a better feeling for the religious aspect of these traditions
One thing to note as your
read: There are two systems of transliteration for Chinese
words. The older spells the "d" sound with the letter "t" and to
express the "t" sound uses an apostrophe (as in the word t'ien, meaning "heaven"). The newer is
closer to what we expect, and it is what I generally use on these web
pages. The older is what will often be found in the links below.
illustration: Altar in a Daoist
Temple in Hong Kong (my own photo)